Season 2 Ep. 4: In Session with Max Spitzer

Max Spitzer spent nearly two decades in the House Parliamentarian’s Office and wrote the book on House procedure. He joins Gavel In to unpack the rules package new Members adopt on day one, how the Rules Committee became the House’s gatekeeper, and why rules, not people, drive gridlock.

Episode Transcript | Return to Gavel In Homepage

Featured Guest

Max Spitzer spent over 18 years in the Office of the House Parliamentarian, first as an Assistant Parliamentarian and later as Managing Editor of the Parliamentarian's publications office.  As an Assistant Parliamentarian, he worked closely with the Speaker's staff to conduct legislative business on the floor of the House, and advised Members, committees, and staff on House rules and procedure.  As Managing Editor, he edited the most recent three editions of "House Practice: A Guide to the Rules, Precedents, and Procedures of the House" and composed four different volumes compiling the parliamentary precedents of the House.  He spearheaded the development of an internal SQL database of parliamentary proceedings and additionally supervised the office's internship program for undergraduates and law students.  He now works as an independent contractor and is currently consulting for the nonpartisan organization Protect Democracy.

Highlighted and Additional Resources

About the Host

Aubrey Wilson served as former Deputy Staff Director for the Committee on House Administration (CHA) in the 118th Congress under Chairman Bryan Steil. In this role, she coordinated efforts to make the House work more effectively, including overseeing the inaugural session of CHA’s bipartisan Subcommittee on Modernization. Prior, Aubrey served as Director of Oversight and Modernization for CHA under Ranking Member Rodney Davis during the 117th Congress. She is a former House legislative assistant and member of the R Street Institute Governance Policy and federal affairs team. Aubrey’s work remains focused on supporting Congress’ and other parliaments’ internal operations and innovation.

About the Podcast

“Gavel In” is a limited-run explainer podcast series to mentor new Members Elect of the incoming Congress, their staff, and families, to help them prepare for the whirlwind of establishing their new offices, teams and roles in our nation’s capital.

It augments the House of Representatives’ official New Member Orientation and breaks down complex topics in short, easy-to-understand lessons on House Floor operations, office structure and hiring, budgeting, technology, security, ethics, and also the intricacies of parliamentary procedure, rules, and how a bill becomes a law.

Cohosted by POPVOX Foundation’s Managing Director Aubrey Wilson, “Gavel In” is a nonpartisan resource to demystify the experience of working in Congress.

About POPVOX Foundation

POPVOX Foundation is a nonpartisan nonprofit organization with a mission to help democratic institutions keep pace with a rapidly changing world. Through publications, events, prototypes, and technical assistance, the organization helps public servants and elected officials better serve their constituents and make better policy.

Transcript

Season 2 Ep. 4: In Session with Max Spitzer

Aubrey Wilson: Welcome back to Gavel In, a podcast produced by POPVOX Foundation to help newly elected Members of Congress, their families and staff get their feet under them as they prepare for their first session serving in the House. I'm your host, Aubrey Wilson. I'm a prior Congressional staffer who worked in both Members' personal offices and for the Committee on House Administration, where I was the director of oversight for the internal operations of the House and modernization initiatives. Today, I'm managing director of POPVOX Foundation, where I work with an incredible team of individuals dedicated to helping Congress work better from the inside out. And this episode is really getting into the nuts and bolts of House floor operations. The House rules. I'm joined by Max Spitzer, one of the few true experts on House parliamentary procedures, having worked nearly two decades within the House parliamentarians office. He was the lead editor of the manual House Practice, a guide to the rules, precedents and procedures of the House, meaning that he quite literally wrote the book on legislative procedure for the House of Representatives. Max and I talk about what Member-elects and their staff need to know to be effective on the floor, what to expect when navigating the modern legislative process. And we dig into the standing rules of the House, that day-one vote that all Members take at the start of a new Congress that locks in the rules of the game for the next two years. Let's gavel in. Well, Max, we're so excited to have you on Gavel In. Thank you so much for joining us.

Max Spitzer: Thank you so much for having me. I'm really excited to be here.

Aubrey Wilson: Okay, so I think that out of all of the people that I've ran into in the Longworth cafeteria in the last months, it has been you. Because I think that you're somebody who when you worked on the Hill, you weren't somebody that I know. I ran into the halls with. But now that you're actually off the Hill, I feel like you've really been making rounds of trying to tell people about your experience of working kind of behind the curtain of one of the most under like. Like, I would say, like, underappreciated. But most, like, most not understood jobs in the House, which is actually the parliamentarians office. So before we actually jump into that, tell our listeners about your career and your experience kind of working in one of the kind of the biggest, most influential behind the scenes offices of the institution?

Max Spitzer: Sure. Happy to. So I was on the Hill for just about 19 years, all of them with the House parliamentarians office. They plucked me right out of law school. So it was basically my only lawyer gig. Now people say, you know, you're a lawyer, you know, you should advise me on contracts or something like that. And I was telling the only, the only law I've ever practiced is the law of the House of Representatives, which is very niche sort of area. And I started in the main office. So we had the parliamentarians had the main office there right off the House floor. And I was, you know, dealing with Members and staff and committees, helping out on the floor, doing the daily legislative business on the floor. And then around 2011, I shifted over to our publications office and focused more on getting our different publications out, doing more kind of deep dive research into the history of the rules, how they evolved over time, and compiling the parliamentary precedents of the House. And so that was my, job through through summer of last year. That's when I left the Hill and was looking for opportunities to, you know, kind of, give that expertise to, to the external world and just share what I learned in the parliamentarians office with others. And I found, a great consulting job with the nonpartisan, nonprofit Protect Democracy, which I'm still working at there. And they have a project on Congressional rules, and they wanted an expert there. So that's where I landed.

Aubrey Wilson: That's awesome. So so I think when you were saying about the parliamentary office, I know when I was a staffer on the Hill, I, I knew that the parliamentary office was right off the off the floor. And, you know, I think everyone has some perception of what the parliamentarian does. But I think in reality, there's so many services that that office provides. Like already you mentioned the publication office. What is kind of the full scope of the parliamentarians office in the House and how it supports Members?

Max Spitzer: Yeah, the parliamentarian office really is kind of a the linchpin of the House. It's really central to, how the House goes about its business. If you if you watch C-SPAN, you see the rostrum up there with the speaker and all these clerks that are doing there, they all have their particular functions. But I kind of the only one that's really kind of coordinating everything is, is the parliamentarian. And there's usually the parliamentarian and a deputy or an assistant on the floor at all times are the ones kind of whispering the magic words into the ear of the Speaker pro tem that's on there. And so that's the kind of the main focus is to sort of get the House through its daily legislative business. In the, in back in the main office, it's where the phones are ringing off the hook. Members and staff of all sorts of questions, committees that were always advising on. It's very hustle bustle sort of place over there. And, a lot of what we do is, you know, helping Members, you know, checking whether their amendments are germane to the bill, whether there are Budget Act points of order, all these sorts of questions. And a lot of what we do is bill referrals. So every Congress, thousands of bills get dropped in the hopper. There could be 50, 100 different bills a day. All of the parliamentarians read through all these bills looking for, committee jurisdictional hooks. You know, which agencies are affected, where the money is coming from, what statutes are being amended? And so we go through all of those bills and, and make the referrals to the, to the committees. So that's kind of the short term immediate functions of the office. And then in the longer term, which was the kind of second half of my career, is those kind of long term projects of documenting the procedures of the House, how it evolved over time, and compiling the, the different parliamentary precedents of the House, the different rulings of the chair. And that was, that's kind of the longer term goal of the parliamentarians. And that's where I got to spend, some important years there.

Aubrey Wilson: That's insane, especially when you think about, once again, like, kind of all of that institutional knowledge that's held in that office and how many years it must take for parliamentarian staffers to get up to speed on that team. Like, what a huge like you said, what a huge career like do once you get pulled into it. I can see why that is like one of those offices institutionally that people stay in for such a long time because like, like so much of it is based on like precedent and prior procedure and that deep understanding of where the rules came from. I know when I started as a junior staffer, one of the very first kind of like common quips I would hear is that if you want to be successful in the Hill, learn the rules. And very often one of the ways that we were told to do that was just to sit and just watch C-SPAN, just watch the floor in action. And I think very quickly you learn that there's not just like the House rules. Like I said, there's like these precedents and there's procedures and, and all these other things. Can you kind of talk about as, as a Member-elect coming in or new staff coming in, what are kind of like all the categories of, I guess, like elements that come into making sure the House functions that kind of Members and staff should be aware of and start to kind of get smart on, to be effective on the floor.

Max Spitzer: Sure. Yeah. So it's, it's kind of a hodgepodge. It's a it's a lot of different things that that affect how the House goes about its business. At the, at the kind of top level there is the Constitution. The Constitution does have some procedural rules in it that the House has to follow everything about, you know, overturning vetoes or calling for recorded votes. Those sorts of things are in the Constitution. So that's kind of the basic grounding of the House rules. Then you have the standing rules of the House, which are adopted at the beginning of each Congress. Usually as part of that package. There will also be what are called separate orders, which are orders of the House, which are not technically in the standing rules, but they function the same way. They are usually kind of temporary rules for just that Congress. And it's a place that, the Members can kind of experiment with rules. So every so often you'll see, like a new budget point of order experimented with as a separate order for a Congress or two. And then maybe if it if it works out, it can be formally incorporated into the standing rules. There are also, what we call the speaker's announced policies. This is another interesting sort of category of, of rule making in the House that the rules give the speaker quite a bit of discretionary authority to go about business in particular ways. And just to give Members kind of a preview of how the speaker is going to exercise those authorities. Since about the mid 80s, the speakers have been inserting into the Congressional Record kind of a list of the protocols and policies that they intend to to abide by during that Congress. And so one one example might be unanimous consent requests, where, you know, you don't necessarily want every Member to have the ability to just come to the floor and ask unanimous consent for my bill to pass and force someone to object to that. So the speaker's statement will say, you know, if it's, if it's cleared by both parties, if, if, if everyone sort of agrees that this is a non-controversial UC request, then the speaker will will entertain that request. But if it's not clear, then the speaker is not going to waste everyone's time with that sort of thing. So that's just an example of sort of it's not binding on the speaker. The speaker isn't, isn't, you know, absolutely forced to abide by these policies, but it does give the Members kind of a heads up on how these different discretionary authorities will be exercised in their in their time in the House. And then we talked a little bit about the precedents of the House. So this is, you know, House abides by this Latin term. Stare decisis is used in judicial proceedings. Let the decision stand. It's basically sort of like once you have made a decision on some procedural issue or whatever, unless there's a compelling reason to to change that later on, you should really stick to that decision and not kind of relitigate all of these different procedural issues again and again. So the classic example is like the germaneness rule. So there's a germaneness rule in the House that says that an amendment has to be germane, it has to be related to the subject matter of the underlying bill. The rule itself is just sort of one sentence like no germane, no non germane amendments are allowed, but it doesn't really tell you what's germane to what, because that's a very kind of case specific situation. So instead, you know someone will offer an amendment on the on the floor. Another Member will make a point of order and say that that's not germane to this bill. The speaker will have to make an official ruling whether it's germane or not. And then record that as a precedent going forward, saying like, this type of amendment is not germane to this type of bill. And so when someone in the future offers that type of amendment to a similar type of bill, the parliamentarians can do that research. Go back to our, our previous notes on these different precedents and say, okay, we've already decided this question. We've already looked at similar bills and similar amendments, and then they can advise the presiding officer, okay, this this one's not germane. This one is so that's sort of how the precedents function. I will also say there are, there are certain kind of administrative regulations in the House. So like, the Committee on House Administration has a number of authorities to kind of, they're less legislative in character, they're more sort of functioning and sort of the administrative level about how Members can use their MRA accounts and stuff like that. So Members should definitely be aware of those sorts of rules and things like the ethics committee, you know, we'll put out even though the ethics rules are part of the standing rules. There are the code of official conduct is in the standing rules. The ethics committee will also give, you know, advice in, you know, a Member's handbook or other specific advice as sort of making more concrete in these particular examples of how to navigate the different ethics rules. And so Members should definitely be aware of those rules as well. And and finally, I'll just say that there are certain kind of, you know, norms and customs that are not, you know, are not binding on anyone. But the House has, you know, 200 and some odd years of traditions now, and some of them get followed with, with a lot of regularity. A good example might be the the magic minute that sometimes gets some play in the media where, it's a tradition that the kind of the main party leaders, the speaker and the minority leader, they're not going to get gaveled down when they start going over their time on the House floor. If you're a regular Member and you're yielded five minutes or whatever, at the end of those five minutes, you know, parliamentarian clerk is up there with a stopwatch and they'll they'll say to the presiding officer, okay, bang the gavel. He's he's done. At some point in the history, they decided, okay, it would be a little uncouth to do that to the speaker. And so the speaker is not going to be on the clock. The speaker and the minority leader can just sort of finish their remarks and not have to be gaveled down. And then it's just a custom that's, that's developed. Now that people have taken that kind of to it's it's logical extreme that, you know, you yield the speaker or the minority leader one minute and then they just go on and on as long as they want. We've seen some interesting filibustering going on under that, that particular custom.

Aubrey Wilson: Now that that that magic minute is definitely something that I think that Members that are are further down the dais has not been there. They get very jealous of that time because the the minutes that are given to the different Members of the debate, they go by very quickly. And so having that that longer minute is something that is very much, very much used. So when it sounds like you have these variety of, kind of elements in play with like keeping the House running for Members coming in, it sounds like so many of them are, like you said, have been set for a while. It sounds like where there is room to to change kind of House dynamics is the standing rules that get adopted at the beginning of every new Congress. And so, they're kind of something that I think a lot of Members who come in. It's one of the very, very first votes they take. It happens very quickly. And I think that a lot of freshmen don't really realize that it was something that they could have engaged on until that they're going into kind of their sophomore term. Can we talk a little bit about what is in that standing rules package and kind of what Members who are Member who are coming in kind of what they should keep an eye out for, where you can even find the standing rules of the current Congress to even know what that package even looks like. Where should somebody start if they're trying to look at the standing House rules?

Max Spitzer: Yeah. So definitely the standing rules are going to be the main source of of how the House conducts its business. And so Members, new Members especially should definitely get familiar with with the rules as soon as they can. Because as you said, it is it is one of the first votes. It's basically the first vote after you elect the speaker to, is to adopt the standing rules of the House. The House, unlike the Senate, it's not a continuing body. So the Senate, you know, only turns over a third of its membership each election. So it sort of continues throughout time, and its rules just continue on without any kind of formal votes on them. In the House, you reconstitute the House every two years. And so they have to elect a new speaker, and they have to adopt a theoretically entirely new rules. Every single, every single Congress. In practice, the rules package, which is usually House resolution five of the new Congress, it's usually in the form of, well, let's take the last Congress's rules and adopt them with some little tweaks and changes here. Usually, whatever the majority party leadership, thinks it would be improvements to the rules based on their experience. And so those that rules package is, is up for debate on that first opening day. And a lot of Members, you know, are don't realize what they're kind of locking themselves into at that point because those rules are going to govern the proceedings for the next two years. And so it's very important to to get a handle on what those what those rules are in terms of finding the rules, you know, on the, on the Rules Committee website has a very good, links to all the current rules and then past rules, usually shortly after the Congress convenes and the rules package is adopted, the clerk will put out a package that is just the annotated formal standing rules of the House, usually that goes up on the clerk's website pretty soon after the rules package is adopted, and then the parliamentarians will put together the House Rules and Manual later in the spring, which is the annotated rules. And so those will contain all of the proceedings from, from prior congresses. And the annotations and Members can, can dig into those. It's it's, you know, a thousand page document at this point. So it's a little, a little bit tricky to get into. One of the other publications that the parliamentarians put out is a is a volume called House Practice, which can also be found on govinfo.gov, is is the main GPO website where you can find a lot of these things. House practice is intended as a as a more kind of user friendly guide to the rules. It's divided by subject matter rather than rules, so it's a little bit easier to find particular topics that you're interested in, but it is quite detailed in itself is is a thousand page document. So it's getting into those is finding exactly what you're looking for can be a little bit tricky even there. So those are the main sources of of where people can can find the rules.

Aubrey Wilson: Can I ask you just after years and years of working on, you know, those publications and then working in the parliamentarians office, how many Members do you think read those larger annotated versions of the rules to really understand the rules and precedents, precedents directly?

Max Spitzer: I would say zero. Maybe, maybe some of the Members on the Rules Committee that is a little bit more focused on procedure. Maybe they have a little bit more experience with the rules and have more, more need to kind of, dig into the details of it. But for the most part, Members, you know, are happy to defer to party leaders who are coordinating things more often and just kind of trust that they know what they're doing and that they are following the rules as as they're written.

Aubrey Wilson: Well, that has to be so, so frustrating, right? Because like the the rules in a lot of ways are like the Members parliamentary rights are in there. It's hard to know which ones are being exercised appropriately or not, unless you really know what's in them, to then continue to improve them as the Members who are the institution for the next version of the rules, the next session. Right. And so, yeah, that has to be something that that I think, you know, could be some, some Member engagement there, because I think that so many just hit the ground running as soon as they get sworn in and they just have this absolute tidal wave hit them of committee assignments and everything else. I don't think that a lot of them take the time to realize that those are resources available to them, and that it really helps them understand what kind of rights they can exercise to move things along.

Max Spitzer: Yeah, absolutely. When you when you talk about the parliamentary rights, that's, that's something that I don't think a lot of Members really, really realize what those, what those rights entail fundamentally, I, I generally kind of divide it into, into four categories of rights that, that Members have as, as Members of this institution when they, when they arrive to, to substantive rights and then to more procedural rights. So, you know, are the substantive rights, I would say are the rights to debate and to vote. So there's the kind of the main parliamentary prerogatives that you have as a Member of Congress is to come down to the floor of the House and and give voice to your constituents and, say what what you believe about the legislation that that's coming before the House. Obviously there are kind of, necessary balances there with that particular. Right, because, you know, it's a it's a body of 435 Members. They can't they can't all have like, full freedom to just talk as much as they want. If every Member wanted to give, you know, even just a one minute speech on any given bill, it would take seven plus hours to get through all of that. So there has to be some some balance there for sure. And at the same time, another point I would make here is just, you know, talk is cheap in some ways. Like, you know, the days of coming down to the House floor and giving, you know, a stirring address that shifts the entire body over to your position. Those those days are long gone. And, there are just so many more ways for people to communicate these ideas to their constituents. You know, back in the in the 19th century, a lot of Members found it really important to be able to get debate time on the House floor, because then the remarks would be transcribed for the Congressional Record, and then they could take those Congressional Records and mail them out to their constituents. And it's like, this is what I said on the on the House floor. Now we have C-SPAN cameras, we have the internet, we have social media. We have all sorts of different ways. And so getting debate time on the floor is not quite the same thing that, that it used to be back in the day. And of course, the, the general ability of Members to insert things into the Congressional Record is still is still protected in the House. Basically, on any bill, you can submit a statement to the record. Even if you don't get debate time on the floor, you can still make your your your point known. You can you can be part of that legislative history by inserting something into the Congressional Record. So, so that's parliamentary, right? Number one is debating. Voting obviously is kind of self-explanatory. And that's that's very protected in the House. There's never any question of of taking away a Member's right to vote on any particular question. What I would say here is that, you know, it depends on a lot depends on on what you're voting on, you know, are did you have an impact in terms of, you know, what's coming up on the agenda, or are you just kind of ratifying decisions that are made elsewhere by party leaders or someone else in some committee somewhere? And so, a lot of, and some of the other sort of issues with, with, with your right to vote is, you know, how much, how much are party leaders, like bundling different things together so that you're taking a single vote on maybe 20 different kind of items? That's that's a very different question than if you're able to take individual votes on, on different items. And brinksmanship is another factor I would bring in here is that, you know, party leaders, you know, maybe coming to the coming to the floor with a, with a package of legislation and, and and saying, you know, it's, we got to vote on this very quickly and there's, there's a deadline here. And you better, you know, vote the way that that we want you to vote. So that's even though your, your right to vote is protected, the context in which that vote occurs is, is very important. The two procedural rights that I like to point out to Members, at the end of the day, you know, all these different motions to refer and recommit and postpone and all that. They all basically come down to two things. It's either agenda or amendment. You're either talking about, you're either looking at the pile of possible bills that could be brought to the floor and deciding which ones are going to come up and in what order. Or once you're decided on a particular bill and we're on H.R. 123, who's going to be allowed to suggest changes to that bill? Who's going to be allowed to, put their ideas into the bill on the House floor via amendment? And so those are two procedural rights that really, kind of determine how power in the House is distributed. And so I think it's very incumbent upon new Members to be aware of how exactly those rights are distributed across, across the different actors within the system, how those different balances, are being made and whether they agree with them fundamentally.

Aubrey Wilson: So then let's dig into the Rules Committee, because I think that that's another committee that a lot of Americans don't know about. Like, just like the general public doesn't hear a whole lot about the Rules Committee. And then when you look at like the Rules Committee, dynamic parliamentarians office where these rules are coming down, who is enforcing them, then you throw in party leadership. It takes a while to kind of understand all the players in the space and how they coordinate together. So can you shine a little bit of light on how the Rules Committee has played into some of these rules, and how it affects the House floor?

Max Spitzer: Yeah, absolutely. The House Rules Committee is is arguably the most powerful committee in the House. It's really kind of the most important committee. And I think the takeaway from this is just to appreciate how, how kind of ad hoc and arbitrary the rules can be, given the power of the Rules Committee. So if you don't mind, I'll go into a little bit of the history of the Rules Committee and how how we kind of got to this point, you know, in the, in the 19th century, the Rules Committee was this kind of on again, off again sort of committee just dealing with the standing rules. It would not be constituted every Congress. But just on occasion, when people felt like there was some particular problem with the rules, you know, they would form the Rules Committee again and had them investigate it. And somewhere in there, I think in the maybe the 1840s, the Rules Committee got this privilege to come to the floor immediately and bring their rules changes immediately to the membership, just at a recognition of these are important matters about how the House conducts its business. And if there's a problem with the rules, then the Rules Committee should be able to get to the floor and and fix that problem by by suggesting changes to the standing rules. And towards the end of the 19th century, Members. Kind of, you know, looked at this power and, and someone came along with the idea of, well, if the Rules Committee can come to the floor at any time and suggest changes to how the House can how the House processes every bill, potentially, then surely it can come to the floor and, change the rules for a specific bill. Just one bill that's sort of a lesser included function of of this same power of changing the rules broadly. Let's change the rules very specifically. And so the Rules Committee could then come to the come to the floor and say, okay, the regular rules of the House, they're not going to do it for this bill. We need special rules for this bill to kind of expedite its consideration. And this is the advent of the special order of business resolution from the Rules Committee, or a special rule. And that's what the Rules Committee has done ever since kind of 1880s, 1890s. They come to the floor. They had this privilege to come to the floor at any time. And they offer this resolution that says, you know, the regular rules are are waived or suspended. We need a set of special rules for this bill. And that's that's how we're going to, consider this particular bill. And it wasn't too long before people realized the power of this, this kind of procedure. And soon enough, special orders, you know, took over the entire procedural landscape at this point. And basically everything that the House has done since that time has been through special orders of business from the Rules Committee. And, you know, I, I think there's an important factor here in terms of kind of just basic rule of law principles that like, you know, you set out the standing rules and these are the these are the expectations that Members have in terms of how how a bill becomes a law, how how bills get considered in the House. But if you have the Rules Committee coming in every day and saying those rules aren't going to work for this bill, and, and the Rules Committee is doing that, like literally every week, every day saying the rules are no good for this bill. The rules are no good for this bill. If everything's a special order, then kind of nothing is a special order. And everything is very, very kind of ad hoc. Members don't really have a good sense of, you know, how this particular bill is going to be brought up because the Rules Committee has such, such broad power to kind of structure the debate on those sorts of things. And so that's something that that Members should definitely be aware of.

Aubrey Wilson: So from my when I, I was trying to think back to when I was a legislative staffer and tracking bills, it definitely seemed, correct me if I'm wrong, but essentially every bill, if it's assuming a somewhat regular order, every bill introduced by a Member gets, sent to a committee from parliamentarian's office. gets assigned a committee of jurisdiction is considered by that committee. If it gets passed out of committee, then it almost always goes to Rules Committee. Which Rules Committee will then decide how it comes to the floor. And so it really is like double its double committee consideration, like the Rules Committee really is the filter that everything kind of has to pass through to get like that leadership sign off to get to the floor for actual Member vote.

Max Spitzer: Yeah, absolutely. That's that's that's totally correct. And, yeah, just to to build off of my point earlier, about the kind of the regularity of the, of the proceedings, you know, there is a daily order of business and the House rules, it's in rule 14, which lists, you know, certain sort of sort of like a, you know, an HOA or something, you know, new business, old business reports kind of thing. It's got a list there that theoretically, the House should be going through every day. And, the House, you know, does the first couple of them, it does the prayer, it does the Pledge of Allegiance, it does the approval of the journal. So it does, you know, numbers one, two and three on that list. And then immediately the Rules Committee comes in and says, we've got special privileged business. We can interrupt the flow of, of this kind of more regular proceeding. And then the House adopts that special rule. They go through the procedure, procedures of that special rule, and then the House never, never comes back to that list. They go to the end of the day under special orders, and then someone moves to adjourn. And that's that's the end of it. And so, it is it is a very kind of strange process. You know, when I tell people, the most important rule to to learn is, is really clause six of rule 13. That's where all the Rules Committee powers are lodged. That's kind of the only rule you need to know at the end of the day, because every day the Rules Committee is going to be coming to the floor and saying all of the other rules are are going to be irrelevant for this particular bill. We're going to have special rules for this bill.

Aubrey Wilson: I think that goes back to what we were talking about earlier, about how many Members have actually sat down and read the rules. I feel like so many Members, it's just out of your control. Like you can introduce the bill, but then once you introduce the bill and it gets assigned to committee and unless you're on that committee, it really is just it's almost at the whim of all of this different, these different dynamics with whether that bill progresses anywhere in the institution. And then let alone if it actually gets through committee and then it has the opportunity to go to the floor, it just seems so out of Members, individual actions to have there be progress on that?

Max Spitzer: Yeah. And there's there's definitely a difference between kind of a set fixed order of business where you introduce your bill and you kind of set it at the beginning of this conveyor belt, and then you kind of assume that the conveyor belt is going to take it through certain stages. A lot of what we see in the House today is as the conveyor belt is not moving, or it doesn't move unless there's a particular gatekeeper there who wants to kind of crank the wheel and make make sure that it does turn. And so when Members introduce their bills, it's it's not like they have a great kind of predictive path about where exactly that bill is going to go, because you don't really know if the committee is going to if the subcommittee is going to take a look at it, if the full committee is going to take a look at it, even if it gets through those stages, you don't know if the Rules Committee is going to make it in order. And yeah, it's just a very different sort of way of operating.

Aubrey Wilson: So with your tenure on the Hill, with what we've kind of seen these last couple Congresses, is this what modern Congressional history looks like or is this something that is more new?

Max Spitzer: Yeah. It's, it's interesting. I, I generally tend to think that a lot changed in the 1970s. We sort of at the we're kind of at the end of this, this period in House history that has gone from quite, quite liberal open procedures that give Members a lot of opportunities to, to influence legislation to a much more centralized, structured sort of place. And so, before, before, you know, the kind of the norms throughout much of the mid 20th century, say, would be, you know, committee chairs, coming to the Rules Committee and, and sort of saying, okay, we want our bills on the floor on this particular day. And the the metaphor that's, that's used in this time period is the Rules Committee is the traffic cop that, you know, all the committees are coming to this intersection, and the Rules Committee is just kind of waiving certain committees through in order to keep the flow of legislation going. It's it's more of a scheduling body than, than anything else. And the Rules Committee would, would put these, put all the bills under, under open rules, which are special orders that allow any Member to come to the floor and offer any germane amendment to the bill. Now, when you talk about voting procedures, if you wanted to do like a full roll call vote back in the 50s or 60 or whatever, you know, it's it's a time consuming process. If you want to do a full roll call, you're reading out Members names. You know, all 435. It takes you a good, you know, half an hour to get through that list if you wanted a full recorded vote on anything. So they came up with shorter ways to to do quicker ways to do votes. The two most common being division votes and teller votes. And so the division vote is just a standing vote where the ayes stand up and the speaker counts them, and then the noes stand up and the speaker counts them reports. Who who voted or how many voted which way. And then teller votes are similar. There are different aisles in the House. There's a, there would be an aye aisle and a no aisle. And then you position Members or clerks at the end and they would just sort of count the Members that pass. Pass by them and then report those totals to the to the speaker. And the speaker would announce, you know, a hundred Members ran through the through the aye aisle and 90 Members ran through the no aisle. So the amendment is adopted, that kind of thing. And what you'll notice about those, those ways of doing these quick votes is that they are anonymous votes. And so no Member is on record as supporting or opposing whatever the the amendment or the bill was that was under consideration. And so this this takes a big change in the 1970s with the advent of the electronic voting system. So in the early 70s, the House put in its electronic voting system. Now Members can just insert their voting card into the machine and press the green button for yea and the and the red button for no. And, and you can do a full recorded vote of every Member of the House in, in as little as two minutes. And so you can in what would have taken, you know, hours and hours before hand now can be done very quickly and you can get everyone on record. The other technological change in the in the 70s was also televised broadcasts of the House procedure proceedings. And so, now Members aren't in the same kind of intimate forum on the House floor where they're just talking to each other and perhaps, you know, taking the business a little bit more seriously about, you know, what, what will actually improve the bill. Now they can kind of grandstand a little bit more. They can talk to the C-SPAN camera as they can talk to their constituents. They can give these rousing speeches on the House floor. And an important moment in that history is, is when Newt Gingrich is elected for the first time in the 70s, and he realizes that he can kind of weaponize the system in a little bit. He can give these stirring speeches on the House floor, and he can offer a bunch of amendments on controversial topics in the committee of the whole, and get those recorded votes that are now very easy to do with the electronic voting system. And so he can offer poison pill amendments of different kinds, get Members on record on hot button, controversial issues and, you know, get get the attack ads out there on different, you know, Members having to take particular positions on these different controversial issues. And so that kind of puts a new dynamic in House operations at that point. And the reaction from a lot of the committee chairs during this time was to go to the speaker and the Rules Committee and say, okay, I want my bill on the floor, but we do if we do it under an open rule like we used to do in the past, Gingrich and his friends are going to offer hundreds of poison pill amendments. They're going to bog everything down. They're going to get us on record, on all these different things, these tough votes that we don't want to take. Can we please get some protection for our bills? And the speaker and the Rules Committee is more than happy to to oblige them and, you know, put in, put in more restrictive procedures. You know, we're not going to do open rules anymore. Maybe there's going to be time limits on particular sections of the bill, just to cut down on the number of amendments that can be offered, or there's going to be a printing requirement where at least we can see what amendments are going to come up and be prepared for them. Or how about we just have the Rules Committee prescreening all the amendments in advance, and they can let through the serious ones, and they can filter out all of the poison pill, bad faith amendments. And you see, over the course of the 80s and 90s under the speaker, Democratic speakers, you know, tip O'Neill. Jim Wright. Tom Foley, during this era, the Rules Committee just gets more and more aggressive in terms of keeping those amendments off the floor, keeping their procedures a little bit more restrictive, screening out amendments in different ways. When Newt Gingrich himself becomes speaker in 1995, he he just accelerates that that process. He, he takes takes away a lot of power of the committee chairs and kind of brings them into the leadership structure. And he obviously has no interest in giving Democrats a whole lot of opportunities to offer their poison pills, any more than they appreciated him being bringing poison pills to the to the body in previous eras. So he, he and the Rules Committee just continue to, to ratchet up the more and more restrictive rules. And somewhere in there, the kind of dynamic between committee chairs and the Rules Committee kind of flips instead of, instead of committee chairs, kind of expecting a certain amount of deference from the Rules Committee and expecting, you know, their rule, their bills would be on the floor under these open procedures. Now they are requesting, you know, certain protections from the Rules Committee. And the Rules Committee starts to think of itself as as the one in the driver's seat at this point. And they can come in and, Now, now, now it's the Rules Committee that can, you know, take a look at the committee, what the committee has done and, you know, get a lot more aggressive, not not only in terms of, like, making the process more restrictive, fewer and fewer amendments, more prescreened amendments, more closed rules where no one can offer any amendments, but also, you know, putting on the floor unreported bills, bills that haven't gone through the committee process. These are basically just leadership. Directed bills. Or they take the committee product and kind of shove it aside and say, okay, what's going to be on the floor is not the committee's version of the of the bill, but the Rules Committee's version of the bill. So they'll offer the Rules Committee print as the base text that Members work from. And, in my time, it's, you know, when I, when I first got to the Hill in 2006, it was kind of the tail end of open rules. They still did a few of the appropriations bills under open rules, because that's where Members really wanted to have the most influence. But those quickly got tightened up as well. And, and in the modern House, in, in this most recent Congress, you've seen special orders that, you know, it's not just it's not just one bill that it's going to be making an order, but it could be the entire the entire week's agenda is going to be a single special order. It makes an order ten different bills. It may waive all sorts of points of order and other things, other statutory rules, things like war powers or the tariff tariff authorities. Those things can all be packaged into a special order as well. And Members don't have any way to kind of break apart those packages. It's a single up or down vote on the entire week's agenda. And so you see a lot more Members kind of realizing this and withholding their votes on these rules packages. You see some kind of rebellious Republicans in the majority in this Congress saying that they can, thinking that they can get some concessions out of leadership by withholding their votes on rules. And then, you know, you see, Speaker Johnson like holding votes open for quite a long time in order to kind of give those concessions and twist those arms and, and get people on board with the plan. At the same time, we've also seen recently some Democratic Members voting in favor of Republican special orders, because they see in this package, they see a bill that they really want on the floor. And they may hate everything else in this package, but they may know that this is the only opportunity for this bill to come up to the floor. And so they have to vote for that rules, that special order from the Rules Committee, if they want to have any chance of of seeing that bill on the floor.

Aubrey Wilson: Okay. So putting yourself in the shoes of a Member or new staffer who's walking into this, like with the dynamics at play, what do you do? Like what is your like what is your tip to to have any type of influence here, to have a strategy of how to be successful, knowing that this is kind of the current dynamic of what the Rules Committee has turned into, how the House rules seem to almost continually disempower Members. What's your what's your advice?

Max Spitzer: Yeah, that's that's a very good question. It was it was always kind of a mystery to me in a lot of ways. How why, why Members would agree to this set of rules that really do kind of, centralize authority and empower the party leaders and people at the top of the hierarchy and really disempower the rank and file Members, especially when they get to the the end of the Congress and they start complaining, oh, I wish I had more opportunities to do things. I wish I had had more power. But, you know, they voted for the rules package at the beginning of that Congress. So they, they're they're responsible for, for that, that state of affairs fundamentally. And I always wondered why why exactly they, they would do this. And the answer I came up with was, you know, to some extent, to the extent that they, they know anything about how the system works and how the rules operate, I think the calculation goes something like this that like, you know, they could advocate for, very fair rules that allow everyone to kind of participate, including them, give them a lot more power. But they but doing so would also give all of their political opponents the same opportunities and the same ability to offer bills and amendments and, and, cause a lot of potentially tough votes for them. Their, their political opponents are going to be able to put things on the floor that they don't want to vote on, that it's going to be, you know, they're going to be cross pressured from different angles. It's going to be a tough vote for them. They, you know, this particular amendment may sound good to their constituents, but not to their donors or vice versa. And so, they would rather just not see those sorts of things on the floor. And so I think they're, they're calculation which is, which is perfectly rational, would be to, to say, okay, we're, we're fine with these kind of very centralized, autocratic rules in some way because my, my guy is in the speaker's chair. And if I just empower the speaker to push forward the party agenda, then I can avoid all of those tough votes. The speaker can protect me from from all of those, those those tough votes that I don't want to have to take. And I can use my influence within the majority party caucus to get my priorities into the bills, whether it's directly through, you know, through just backroom kind of negotiations. I want my idea in this bill in order to get my support for this bill or, you know, with the the Rules Committee to make my amendment in order so that I can get a chance to to weigh in on this particular bill. And so I think that's the kind of rational calculation, to the extent that Members do think about that in any way. I think probably the more likely explanation is just ignorance, just like unfamiliarity with the House rules, especially given that, you know, the election happens early November, you've got barely two months to get situated. There's so much to do in those two months setting up kind of this entire small business operation of running a Congressional office. There's so much stuff that you need to learn in those two months. The exact, contours of the different rules are really probably the last thing that they're thinking of. And as we talked about like that, rules vote is kind of one of the first things they do. And they lock themselves in right at the beginning there. So yeah. So my general advice is to learn as much as you can about the House rules as quickly as possible and, understand how they operate and understand the kind of trade offs that, that you're making when you vote for that rules package. It's not just, you know, trusting leadership to exercise certain authorities in certain ways, like you are. You are giving them these authorities. And if you're uncomfortable with them having those authorities, you should be thinking about what what alternative ways of running the House would you like to see? And there's there's there's a lot of different ways to run the House. There's a lot of a lot of history of a more decentralized structures that have been used in the past. And so there's lots of different ways of, of, of running the House and constructing the rules. And so Members should definitely become familiar, as familiar as they can with, with the current system and how they would like to, to see the institution operate.

Aubrey Wilson: So Max, I'm curious. So we talked a lot about the rules package and kind of that dynamics. We also talked about how so many of the rules can be arbitrary, just based on kind of who sits on the Rules Committee and obviously who the speaker is, which kind of leads to a lot of the criticism that I sometimes hear about the House, that maybe the rules aren't the issue is just the fact that the people are the issue. Like, how much should Members believe the dynamic that they're walking into is, is actually because the rules don't work versus the fact that just politicians are just how they are these days with kind of House dynamics.

Max Spitzer: Yeah, that is definitely a criticism that I see from from a lot of commentators. And I try to push back against that and say, we don't really have a people problem. We have a rules problem. At the end of the day, you know, a lot of people will say, you know, we just need to elect different people. The people that get into the House and the Senate, they they're they're unwilling to compromise. They're stubborn, they're partisans, they're stupid, they're lazy, they're corrupt. And and, of course, you know, in a body of 435 people, you're going to get some, some outliers, you're going to get the grandstanders and the show voters and the people who are not really interested in legislating. But at the end of the day, the American people are actually pretty good at selecting Members to represent them. And it's really just the fact that the Members kind of get chewed up into this system that doesn't really allow them to, to play to their strengths. You know, there they are for the most part. You know, my experience with Members has been that they are quite dedicated public servants, that they are competent, they intelligent, well-meaning, and they want to give a voice to their constituents. And, it's, it's really that they, they come into a system that they, that they don't, fully understand and don't fully appreciate where the different, power centers in the House are and how the different. Procedural rights are distributed throughout the chamber. And if we were able to kind of fix those, those rules in different ways, then I think, I think you'd see a much more functional House at the end of the day.

Aubrey Wilson: When I can't. I'm I would say I can't agree with that enough, because I know that was my experience working in the House was just how hard Members and staff work, and I know that that was one of the reasons I've gotten so pulled into Congressional modernization over the years was just understanding that everyone that gets elected, everyone who decides to work in the Capitol and a district office, they're all there to truly serve their community and make the country work better. I didn't meet a single person that was a malicious actor. And I know I was just pulling up congress.gov for anyone who's listening who doesn't go there and and watch those bill counts come in. There's been almost 13,000 bills introduced this Congress. And that's insane. Like, that shows how much work and ideas and legislative product is being made and done by these offices. But it's just not getting to the finish line. And like you said, with the trend that we've been seeing across the House since the 1970s, it clearly isn't, you know, and with new classes of Members coming in every two years, if it was a people problem, I feel like you'd see a variety of productivity happening. And it really has just kind of consistently been declining as those as those rules of change. And so, so, yeah, you've you've convinced me.

Max Spitzer: Yeah, absolutely. The, the the idea that we're living in some unique period of history where the Members are particularly bad, I just I just don't believe that I think Members throughout history, you know, have been more or less. The kind of, kind of the same over, over the course of history. And, and I think that there is a real opportunity in the next Congress to, and to take some of the, the energy of the new Members and, and change kind of how things are going to be done. I just finished Dr. Kornberg's book, Stuck, which talks about different wave classes in Congress. And, you know, given the, the number of retirements in this Congress. You know, wave election or no, there's going to be a lot of new faces, potentially, you know, a hundred new Members coming to Congress. And Doctor Kornberg talks about harnessing the freshness of the Members that they they come to the institution. And and I remember my first day kind of on the House floor, kind of just looking around and being like, oh my God, I can't believe I'm here. This is so amazing. I, I'm so energized to, like, do good things for the country. And, and Members have that same feeling. And so if we can get the new Members to kind of lean into that a little bit and, and recognize the power that they have over the institution, over the rules of the institution, then I think we'll see some, some real positive change.

Aubrey Wilson: Yeah. I like to, whenever I have the opportunity to talk to a new Member, I like to always remind them that, you know, the House and I should say, like the House and Senate. You know, they're obviously chambers and they're in this beautiful building, but like, the institution is the people like, you know, if you think of, you know, the actual Members themselves, they are what makes up the body. And as this huge class is coming in, man, do they have an opportunity if they are not happy with the way things work and opportunity to kind of shift that path a different direction, or at least, like you said, experiment with new rules in some way, shape or form to test out of how the process could be better in the modern era. Even though you have recorded votes with the electronic voting cards, and even though you have televised proceedings, how can we update this and have there be more in the modern time? How can we think differently and like and like, you know, Doctor Kornberg said, like you just echoed like, how can we kind of take advantage of kind of some fresh perspective to see if maybe we can get the House and Senate to work a little bit better?

Max Spitzer: Yeah. And I think that also goes not just to rank and file Members, but also, you know, potentially a new leadership team that's coming in. I think the polls are good for for the Democrats to to retake the majority after the next election. You could have, Speaker Jeffries, the first African-American speaker of the House. And, you know, what I would say to him is, you know, you have a real opportunity here to to to chart a new course for the House to kind of be, you know, almost an anti Newt Gingrich who, you know, centralized so much power within the House. A lot of people think, you know, a powerful House is one that has a powerful speaker that can kind of, you know, go toe to toe with the president or something like that. I think of a powerful House as one where all of the Members of the institution have a real investment in what the House is doing, and that requires a certain amount of decentralization that requires, you know, harnessing the power of all of these different new Members who, as we said, you know, our our energetic, they're competent, they want to do good things, put them in positions where they can they can, you know, do the things that that their constituents sent them to Capitol Hill to do.

Aubrey Wilson: Well. And I feel like in this conversation, we really have just been able to go surface level on so many of these topics, and there are so many groups every year or say, every two years in the kind of the DC think tank good governance world that put out packages of rules reform ideas and proposals just to try to insert some new ideas and about what that new kind of rules package could look like. Can you talk a little bit more about the work that you're doing after Protect Democracy, and the kind of continual help that's out there for these Members who are going to try to follow that advice and get smart on rules quickly.

Max Spitzer: Sure. So I've been working for the past year or so with, with Protect Democracy and we just got our, our new website up. So it's, congressionalrenewal.org. And you can go there and see, the package of rules, recommendations that we put out there. They focus on those two kind of main procedural rights that Members have the, the agenda and the amendment, and so different ways to kind of, that we thought of, of kind of slightly opening up the door a little bit. I don't think, the House is really ready for, you know, a full return back to open rules and, and the potential chaos of that kind of thing. But there are ways to kind of structure the institution, to make it a little bit more manageable and provide Members with some more opportunities to, to to have real agency within the institution to not to have to kind of rely on party leaders for everything, but actually give them a little bit more power within the institution. So we have a couple recommendations for these kind of small fixes that I think would be suitable for, you know, right on opening day of the new Congress, I think these are small enough that that they could be instituted without without a whole lot of, problems. Other parts of our recommendation obviously recognize that there are kind of more structural issues with the House rules, kind of more deep seated kind of issues with not only floor procedure, but also committee structure, committee procedure, committee jurisdictions, the budget process as a whole can of worms right there. The ethics process is also something that needs kind of an overhaul. And so one of our other main recommendations is to set up a new select committee to kind of investigate those, those more kind of structural issues. I know you worked on the the former Select Committee on the Modernization of Congress, so we're calling this one Super ModCom, which is kind of a throwback to to what original ModCom was able to accomplish. But like, let's go this step further and give this, this committee a little bit more power to to really change fundamentally how things work on the House floor, to take a look at those those bigger issues, and ideally to have the kind of procedural power to to come to the floor in the same way that the Rules Committee comes to the floor and, and put its recommendations to, to the entire membership and see where Members want to want to adjust things. And so those are definitely, some of the things that we've been promoting over there. I also, you know, hold myself out as someone that that Members can talk to about any of this stuff. I have given different presentations on the House rules and how they operate, different, you know, getting down into the nitty gritty of specific House rules and operations, but also these kind of, broader issues about, you know, your, your parliamentary rights and, and how power is distributed kind of a, at a, at a deep level within the House. And so, yeah, if Member-elects want to get in touch and, and hear a little bit more about how the House rules operates and, and the history of them, more than happy to to go into any of that with anyone who's interested.

Aubrey Wilson: Well, in the episode notes on our website and I'm and across kind of all the resources where this conversation is available, we'll make sure to put links to not only that rules package to Protect Democracy, but to the website and to contact information to you to Max. And I just can't thank you enough. I know the rules really were something that it was so challenging finding resources that translate them to very like to a useful learning kind of dynamic for somebody who is just trying to understand quickly how to get their feet under them and the institution and the work that you're doing since you've left the House to, to finally meet people where they are and explain them in a helpful way. It is truly incredible. And so thank you for your time, for being on Gavel In with me. And also just thank you for your continued dedication to making the House work better from the inside out.

Max Spitzer: Thank you so much for having me. This has been quite a pleasure. Thank you.

Next
Next

Season 2 Ep. 3: In Session with Rep. John Mannion